Festival stage lights: flashing patterns, primes and fractions of a show
1.1 Types of number, factors, HCF and LCM1.2 Fractions, decimals and percentages1.4 Estimation, rounding, bounds, ratio, proportion and moneyCore
At a music festival, three stage lights A, B and C flash during a band’s set.
- Light A flashes every 12 seconds.
- Light B flashes every 18 seconds.
- Light C flashes every 45 seconds.
All three lights flash together at the very start of the set. Figure 1 shows the flashes in the first 60 seconds.
Write 45 as a product of its prime factors.
Show solution
| a correct first split or division, e.g. \(45 = 5\times9\) or \(45\div3=15\) | M1 | A correct factor tree or repeated division with at most one slip. |
| \(3^2\times5\) | A1 | Accept \(3\times3\times5\). Do not accept a list 3, 3, 5 or an answer with + signs. |
Answer: \(3^2\times5\)
Find how many seconds after the start of the set all three lights next flash together.
Show solution
| \(12 = 2^2\times3\) and \(18 = 2\times3^2\) | B1 | Both correct. May be seen in a Venn diagram. |
| LCM \(=2^2\times3^2\times5\) or listing multiples of 45 and testing them against 12 and 18 | M1 | Uses the highest power of each prime from 12, 18 and 45. Allow ECF from (a). |
| 180 | A1 | Accept 3 minutes. 3 (the HCF) scores M0 A0. |
Answer: 180 seconds (3 minutes)
The set lasts exactly 90 minutes.
Find the number of times that all three lights flash together during the set. Do not count the flash at the very start, but do count a flash at the very end.
Show solution
| \(90\times60\div180\) or \(5400\div180\) | M1 | Allow ECF from their (b)(i): their \(5400\div\) their LCM, or \(90\div3\). |
| 30 | A1 | 31 (counting the start) scores M1 A0. |
Answer: 30
Sam says:
“The HCF of 12, 18 and 45 is 3, so all three lights flash together every 3 seconds.”
Explain why Sam is wrong.
Show solution
| lights flash together only at times that are multiples of 12, 18 and 45, i.e. common multiples; 3 is a common factor, not a common multiple | B1 | Any clear statement that a common multiple (LCM) is needed. |
| e.g. light A does not flash at 3 seconds: its first flash after the start is at 12 seconds (Figure 1 shows no flash at 3 s) | B1 | Any correct counter-example from the data or the figure. |
During the set, a laser display is used for \(\frac{1}{4}\) of the time and a smoke effect is used for \(\frac{2}{9}\) of the time. The two effects are never used at the same time.
Show that, for \(\dfrac{19}{36}\) of the set, neither effect is used.
Show solution
| \(\frac{1}{4}=\frac{9}{36}\) and \(\frac{2}{9}=\frac{8}{36}\) | M1 | Both fractions over a common denominator (36 is the LCM of 4 and 9). Any correct common denominator, e.g. 72, is fine. |
| \(1-\frac{17}{36}\) | M1 | Subtracting the total of the two effects from 1, e.g. \(\frac{36}{36}-\frac{9}{36}-\frac{8}{36}\). |
| \(\frac{19}{36}\) | A1 | cso. Decimal working (e.g. 0.25 + 0.222) scores at most M0 M1 A0. |
Answer: \(\frac{19}{36}\) (shown)
Figure 2 shows the energy used by each of the four lighting rigs during the set.
Find the fraction of the total energy that was used by the back rig. Give your answer in its simplest form.
Show solution
| 18, 24, 12 and 6 read from the graph, or a total of 60 | B1 | |
| \(\frac{24}{60}\) | M1 | Their back-rig value over their total. |
| \(\frac{2}{5}\) | A1 | 0.4 or 40% alone scores A0. ECF for the correct simplest form of their fraction. |
Answer: \(\frac{2}{5}\)
Write the ratio
energy used by the back rig : energy used by the front rig : energy used by the strobe rig
in its simplest form.
Show solution
| \(24 : 18 : 6\) or a correct partly simplified ratio, e.g. \(12 : 9 : 3\) | M1 | Values from their readings in (e)(i). |
| \(4 : 3 : 1\) | A1 | Must be in this order. |
Answer: \(4 : 3 : 1\)
For the next set, light C is re-programmed to flash every 40 seconds. Lights A and B do not change. All three lights flash together at the start of the set.
Find how many seconds after the start all three lights next flash together.
Show solution
| \(40 = 2^3\times5\) | B1 | |
| LCM \(=2^3\times3^2\times5\) | M1 | Highest powers of 2, 3 and 5 from \(2^2\times3\), \(2\times3^2\) and \(2^3\times5\); or listing multiples of 40 tested against 12 and 18. |
| 360 | A1 | Accept 6 minutes. |
Answer: 360 seconds (6 minutes)
Show full solution
| Working | Mark | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Part (a) | ||
| a correct first split or division, e.g. \(45 = 5\times9\) or \(45\div3=15\) | M1 | A correct factor tree or repeated division with at most one slip. |
| \(3^2\times5\) | A1 | Accept \(3\times3\times5\). Do not accept a list 3, 3, 5 or an answer with + signs. |
| Part (b)(i) | ||
| \(12 = 2^2\times3\) and \(18 = 2\times3^2\) | B1 | Both correct. May be seen in a Venn diagram. |
| LCM \(=2^2\times3^2\times5\) or listing multiples of 45 and testing them against 12 and 18 | M1 | Uses the highest power of each prime from 12, 18 and 45. Allow ECF from (a). |
| 180 | A1 | Accept 3 minutes. 3 (the HCF) scores M0 A0. |
| Part (b)(ii) | ||
| \(90\times60\div180\) or \(5400\div180\) | M1 | Allow ECF from their (b)(i): their \(5400\div\) their LCM, or \(90\div3\). |
| 30 | A1 | 31 (counting the start) scores M1 A0. |
| Part (c) | ||
| lights flash together only at times that are multiples of 12, 18 and 45, i.e. common multiples; 3 is a common factor, not a common multiple | B1 | Any clear statement that a common multiple (LCM) is needed. |
| e.g. light A does not flash at 3 seconds: its first flash after the start is at 12 seconds (Figure 1 shows no flash at 3 s) | B1 | Any correct counter-example from the data or the figure. |
| Part (d) | ||
| \(\frac{1}{4}=\frac{9}{36}\) and \(\frac{2}{9}=\frac{8}{36}\) | M1 | Both fractions over a common denominator (36 is the LCM of 4 and 9). Any correct common denominator, e.g. 72, is fine. |
| \(1-\frac{17}{36}\) | M1 | Subtracting the total of the two effects from 1, e.g. \(\frac{36}{36}-\frac{9}{36}-\frac{8}{36}\). |
| \(\frac{19}{36}\) | A1 | cso. Decimal working (e.g. 0.25 + 0.222) scores at most M0 M1 A0. |
| Part (e)(i) | ||
| 18, 24, 12 and 6 read from the graph, or a total of 60 | B1 | |
| \(\frac{24}{60}\) | M1 | Their back-rig value over their total. |
| \(\frac{2}{5}\) | A1 | 0.4 or 40% alone scores A0. ECF for the correct simplest form of their fraction. |
| Part (e)(ii) | ||
| \(24 : 18 : 6\) or a correct partly simplified ratio, e.g. \(12 : 9 : 3\) | M1 | Values from their readings in (e)(i). |
| \(4 : 3 : 1\) | A1 | Must be in this order. |
| Part (f) | ||
| \(40 = 2^3\times5\) | B1 | |
| LCM \(=2^3\times3^2\times5\) | M1 | Highest powers of 2, 3 and 5 from \(2^2\times3\), \(2\times3^2\) and \(2^3\times5\); or listing multiples of 40 tested against 12 and 18. |
| 360 | A1 | Accept 6 minutes. |
Answers: (a) \(3^2\times5\) · (b)(i) 180 seconds (3 minutes) · (b)(ii) 30 · (d) \(\frac{19}{36}\) (shown) · (e)(i) \(\frac{2}{5}\) · (e)(ii) \(4 : 3 : 1\) · (f) 360 seconds (6 minutes)
Exam tip (c) Ask yourself whether you are splitting something into equal groups (HCF) or waiting for things that repeat to line up again (LCM). Repeating flashes always need the LCM.
Common error (f) Multiplying the numbers together (\(12\times18\times40\)) gives a common multiple but not the lowest one, because the numbers share factors.