IB Physics SL · first assessment 2025 · Theme D

D.1 Gravitational fields: IB Physics SL exam-style questions

D.1 at SL covers Newton's universal law of gravitation, F = Gm₁m₂/r², for bodies treated as point masses, and the conditions under which an extended body can be treated as one. Gravitational field strength is the force per unit mass, g = GM/r², and fields are drawn with field lines.

Combining gravitation with circular motion lets you analyse orbits, and Kepler's three laws describe planetary motion. Gravitational potential, potential energy −GMm/r and escape speed are Higher Level.

  • 32 questions
  • 197 marks
  • Paper 1A: 16
  • Paper 1B: 5
  • Paper 2: 11
  • Full mark schemes

Showing 506 of 506 questions · 3452 marks

Tick questions to build a test

32 practice questions on D.1 Gravitational fields

1D-1A-01
Newton's law of gravitation·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AEasy1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark1 step to full marksCalculate

Two small spheres, each of mass 5.0 kg, have their centres 0.20 m apart. G = 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2.

What is the gravitational force between them?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1F = Gm₁m₂/r² = 6.67 × 10⁻¹¹ × 5.0 × 5.0/0.20² = 4.2 × 10⁻⁸ N.✓ 1Answer D

Answer: D  ·  1 stage of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThe separation has not been squared. The law is an inverse-square law.
  • BThis is the force at 0.40 m, twice the stated separation.
  • CThis adds the two masses instead of multiplying them, using 10 kg in place of 25 kg².
  • DCorrect: F = 6.67 × 10⁻¹¹ × 25/0.040 = 4.2 × 10⁻⁸ N.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = Gm1m2/r² for bodies treated as point masses Command term: Calculate

2D-1A-02
Gravitational field strength·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark1 step to full marksIdentify

Which statement about the gravitational field strength g at a point is correct?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1g = F/m is defined as force per unit mass on a small point mass. Doubling the test mass doubles F, so F/m is unchanged: the field belongs to the point, not to the test mass.✓ 1Answer C

Answer: C  ·  1 stage of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThis confuses the field strength with the force. The force doubles with the mass, but the force per unit mass does not.
  • BThe acceleration equals g only in free fall. If other forces act, for example a normal force, the acceleration is different.
  • CCorrect: g = F/m is the force per unit mass on a small test mass, so the test mass cancels.
  • DThe unit is right, but g is a vector. It has the direction of the force on a test mass, towards the attracting body.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Identify

3D-1A-03
Variation of g with distance·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDetermine

The gravitational field strength at the surface of a planet of radius R is g.

Point X is a distance 3R from the centre of the planet. Point Y is a height 3R above the surface of the planet.

Which row gives the gravitational field strength at X and at Y?

Field strength at XField strength at Y
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1g ∝ 1/r², with r measured from the centre: X is at r = 3R, and Y is at r = R + 3R = 4R.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2Field at X = g/3² = g/9; field at Y = g/4² = g/16.✓ 1Answer D

Answer: D  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThis uses 1/r instead of 1/r² for both points (3R and 4R).
  • BThis measures both distances from the surface (2R for X and 3R for Y) instead of from the centre.
  • CThis treats the height 3R as a distance 3R from the centre; Y is 4R from the centre.
  • DCorrect: X is 3R and Y is 4R from the centre, so the fields are g/9 and g/16.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Determine

4D-1A-04
Kepler's laws·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AEasy1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark1 step to full marksIdentify

Which statement about the planets of the Solar System agrees with Kepler's laws of orbital motion?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1Kepler's first law: each orbit is an ellipse with the Sun at one focus. (The second law implies the speed varies; the third law, T² ∝ r³, gives longer periods farther out.)✓ 1Answer A

Answer: A  ·  1 stage of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • ACorrect: this is Kepler's first law.
  • BThe Sun is at a focus, not at the centre. Only for a circle do the focus and the centre coincide.
  • CEqual areas in equal times means the planet moves faster when it is nearer the Sun, so its speed is not constant on an ellipse.
  • DThis inverts Kepler's third law: T² ∝ r³, so the period increases with distance from the Sun.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion Command term: Identify

5D-1A-05
Gravitational field lines·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AEasy1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark1 step to full marksIdentify

Which diagram best represents the gravitational field lines around an isolated, uniform spherical planet?

Four diagrams A to D of possible gravitational field-line patterns around a spherical planetA.B.C.D.
Diagrams NOT accurately drawn
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1The force on a small test mass points straight towards the centre of a uniform sphere, so the lines are radial and point inwards; being radial, they crowd together near the surface where the field is strongest.✓ 1Answer C

Answer: C  ·  1 stage of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThe arrows point outwards. Gravity is always attractive, so the field points towards the planet.
  • BClosed loops are a feature of magnetic fields. Gravitational field lines end on the mass.
  • CCorrect: radial lines pointing inwards, closer together near the surface where the field is strongest.
  • DThe lines curve round the planet. For a uniform sphere the force on a test mass points straight at the centre, so the lines must be radial.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — gravitational field lines Command term: Identify

6D-1A-06
Kepler's third law·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDetermine

Two moons, X and Y, move in circular orbits around the same planet. The orbital radius of Y is four times the orbital radius of X.

What is (orbital period of Y)/(orbital period of X)?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1Kepler's third law: T² ∝ r³, so T ∝ r3/2.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2Period ratio = 43/2 = 8.✓ 1Answer C

Answer: C  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThis is 41/2: it takes T ∝ r1/2.
  • BThis takes the period to be proportional to the radius.
  • CCorrect: T ∝ r3/2 and 43/2 = 8.
  • DThis is 4²: it takes T ∝ r², squaring instead of raising to the power 3/2.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion Command term: Determine

7D-1A-07
Variation of g with distance·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksIdentify

The gravitational field strength g is measured at several distances r from the centre of a planet. All the points are outside the planet.

Which graph shows the variation of g with 1/r²?

Four sketch graphs A to D of g against 1/r squaredA.g1/r²0B.g1/r²0C.g1/r²0D.g1/r²0
Sketch graphs, not to scale
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1Outside the planet g = GM/r², so g is directly proportional to 1/r².—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2A graph of g against 1/r² is therefore a straight line of gradient GM through the origin (g → 0 as r → ∞).✓ 1Answer D

Answer: D  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AA positive intercept would mean a non-zero field infinitely far away (1/r² = 0).
  • BThis curve (g ∝ √(1/r²)) is what g ∝ 1/r would give. The field follows an inverse-square law.
  • CA negative gradient treats "inverse" as "decreasing". Plotted against 1/r², the field increases.
  • DCorrect: g = GM × (1/r²), a straight line through the origin with gradient GM.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Identify

8D-1A-08
Combining two gravitational fields·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AHard1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark3 steps to full marksDetermine

Two spheres of mass M and 9M have their centres a distance d apart. At point P on the line joining their centres, between the spheres, the resultant gravitational field strength is zero.

What is the distance of P from the centre of the sphere of mass M?

Sphere of mass M and sphere of mass 9M with centres a distance d apart; point P lies on the line between themM9MPd
Diagram NOT accurately drawn
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1At P the two fields are equal and opposite: GM/x² = G(9M)/(d − x)².—All 3 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2Taking square roots: d − x = 3x.—
Step 3x = d/4 (closer to the smaller mass).✓ 1Answer B

Answer: B  ·  3 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThis sets d − x = 9x, using the mass ratio instead of its square root.
  • BCorrect: (d − x)/x = √9 = 3, so x = d/4.
  • CThe midpoint is the null point only for equal masses.
  • DThis is the distance of P from the larger sphere, not from the sphere of mass M.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is given by g = F/m = GM/r²; the resultant field is restricted to points along the line joining two bodies (guidance) Command term: Determine

9D-1A-09
Extended bodies as point masses·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksExplain

Newton's law of gravitation is stated for point masses, yet it is used to calculate the force between the Earth and the Moon.

Which statement justifies this?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1A spherically symmetric body produces the same external field as a point mass of the same total mass at its centre.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2The Earth and the Moon are very nearly spherically symmetric and far apart compared with their sizes, so the point-mass law applies.✓ 1Answer D

Answer: D  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • ALarge masses give large forces, but that says nothing about whether the point-mass model is valid.
  • BWeakness is not the issue — the model is used for very precise orbit calculations.
  • CThe shape of the orbit has nothing to do with whether a body can be treated as a point mass.
  • DCorrect: a spherically symmetric body attracts external bodies as though all its mass were at its centre.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — conditions under which extended bodies can be treated as point masses Command term: Explain

10D-1B-01
Gravitational field strength·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1BMedium10 marks
Data-based question10 steps to full marksDetermine

A student uses a published satellite catalogue to test how the gravitational field strength g of the Earth varies with the distance r from the Earth's centre. For five satellites in near-circular orbits, the catalogue lists the mean altitude h above the Earth's surface and the orbital period T.

For a satellite in a circular orbit, g at the orbit is equal to the centripetal acceleration a = 4π²r/T². The radius of the Earth is 6.37 × 106 m.

The graph shows a against 1/r² for four of the satellites.

Satelliteh / kmT / minr / 106 ma / m s−21/r² / 10−15 m−2
A41092.66.788.6721.8
B1336112.27.716.7116.8
C8062287.6
D20180717.626.60.5651.42
E357861435.742.20.2240.563
Centripetal acceleration of four satellites against the reciprocal of orbital radius squared048121620241/r² / 10⁻¹⁵ m⁻²0246810a / m s⁻²
Graph drawn to scale
(a)

Show that a for satellite B is about 6.7 m s−2.

(1)
(b)

Complete the table for satellite C.

(2)
(c)

Plot the data point for satellite C on the graph and draw the line of best fit for the data.

(2)
(d)

Determine the gradient of the line. State its unit.

(2)
(e)

Determine the mass of the Earth. Compare your answer with the accepted value of 5.97 × 1024 kg.

(2)
(f)

Suggest one advantage of plotting lg a against lg r for these data.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
r = 6.37 × 106 + 1.336 × 106 = 7.706 × 106 m AND a = 4π² × 7.706 × 106/(112.2 × 60)² = 6.71 m s−2✓ 1Must see full substitution with T in seconds OR answer to at least 3 s.f.
Part (b)
r = 14.4 × 106 m AND 1/r² = 4.80 × 10−15 m−2✓ 1Accept 1/r² in the range 4.79–4.81.
a = 4π² × 14.43 × 106/(287.6 × 60)² = 1.91 m s−2✓ 1Must be given to 3 s.f., consistent with the rest of the table.
Part (c)
Point plotted at (4.80, 1.91) to within half a small square✓ 1
Single straight line passing through (or very close to) all five points and the origin✓ 1Do not accept a line joining the dots or a curve.
Part (d)
Gradient calculated from a triangle using at least half the length of the line✓ 1
gradient = 3.99 × 1014 m³ s−2✓ 1Accept 3.90 × 1014 to 4.10 × 1014. Accept N m² kg−1. Unit required for this mark.
Part (e)
M = gradient/G = 3.99 × 1014/6.67 × 10−11 = 5.98 × 1024 kg✓ 1Allow ECF from (d). Accept 5.85 × 1024 to 6.15 × 1024 kg.
Differs from the accepted value by about 0.1 %, so the two agree / the data support g = GM/r²✓ 1The comparison must be consistent with the candidate's value; a percentage difference or a clear statement of closeness is required. OWTTE
Part (f)
The points would be spread more evenly across the graph (here four of the five points lie near the ends of the range) OR the gradient gives the power of r directly, so the inverse-square relationship (gradient −2) is tested without being assumed✓ 1OWTTE

Answers: (a) a = 6.71 m s−2  ·  (b) r = 14.4 × 106 m; a = 1.91 m s−2; 1/r² = 4.80 × 10−15 m−2  ·  (d) 3.99 × 1014 m³ s−2  ·  (e) M = 5.98 × 1024 kg (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Determine

11D-1B-02
Variation of g with height·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1BHard11 marks
Data-based question11 steps to full marksDetermine

A student investigates how the gravitational field strength g varies with height h above the ground. A portable gravimeter is carried by lift to different floors of a tall office building. On each floor it measures the change Δg in g relative to a reference point at street level. Each value of Δg is the mean of several readings and has an uncertainty of ±10 μm s−2; the uncertainty in h is negligible.

For h much smaller than the radius R of the Earth, g = GM/(R + h)² leads to Δg = −(2g0/R)h, where g0 = 9.81 m s−2 is the field strength at street level.

The graph shows the data with error bars.

h / mΔg / μm s−2
40−111
80−236
120−345
160−467
200−576
240−701
Change in gravitational field strength against height, with error bars050100150200250h / m−800−700−600−500−400−300−200−1000Δg / μm s⁻²
Graph drawn to scale
(a)

The gravimeter displays readings to the nearest 0.1 μm s−2. Suggest why the uncertainty in Δg is much larger than this.

(1)
(b)

Draw the line of best fit for the data.

(1)
(c)

Determine the gradient of the line and its absolute uncertainty. Draw lines of maximum and minimum gradient on the graph.

(3)
(d)

Determine, from your answer to (c), the radius R of the Earth and its absolute uncertainty.

(2)
(e)

The accepted value of R is 6.37 × 106 m. Comment on the student's result.

(1)
(f)

The building has a very large mass. Explain how the gravitational attraction of the building affects the measured values of Δg and hence the value of R obtained.

(2)
(g)

Suggest one improvement to the investigation.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
Repeated readings vary/fluctuate (e.g. because of vibration or sway of the building, lifts, traffic, wind), so the spread of the readings, not the resolution, sets the uncertainty✓ 1OWTTE
Part (b)
Single straight line passing through all the error bars with the points scattered on both sides✓ 1Line does not need to pass through the origin.
Part (c)
Best gradient = −2.92 × 10−6 s−2✓ 1Accept −2.87 to −2.97 × 10−6 s−2 (μm s−2 per m). Sign not required.
Max and min gradient lines drawn through all the error bars, with gradients of about −3.00 × 10−6 and −2.85 × 10−6 s−2✓ 1
Uncertainty = ½(max − min) ≈ ±0.07 × 10−6 s−2✓ 1Accept ±0.05 to ±0.12 × 10−6 s−2. Allow the larger of (max − best) and (best − min).
Part (d)
R = 2g0/|gradient| = 2 × 9.81/2.92 × 10−6 = 6.7 × 106 m✓ 1Allow ECF from (c).
ΔR = R × (Δgradient/gradient) ≈ 0.2 × 106 m, so R = (6.7 ± 0.2) × 106 m✓ 1MP2 is for the uncertainty with matching precision of value and uncertainty. Accept an uncertainty range 6.54–6.88 × 106 m from the max/min gradients.
Part (e)
The accepted value lies (just) outside the student's range, so the result is not consistent with it: there is a systematic error / the result is too large✓ 1Allow ECF from (d).
Part (f)
On the upper floors most of the building's mass is below the gravimeter and pulls downwards (at street level it is above and pulls upwards), so Δg is less negative than for the Earth alone✓ 1OWTTE
The magnitude of the gradient is too small, so R = 2g0/|gradient| is too large — consistent with (e)✓ 1Award MP2 only if the direction of the effect on the gradient is correct.
Part (g)
Repeat the measurements on a structure of much smaller mass (e.g. an open lattice mast) OR correct the readings for the building's own attraction OR extend the range of heights to reduce the percentage uncertainty in the gradient✓ 1Accept any specific, relevant improvement. Do not accept “repeat the readings” without further detail.

Answers: (c) −2.92 × 10−6 s−2 ± 0.07 × 10−6 s−2  ·  (d) R = (6.7 ± 0.2) × 106 m (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Determine

12D-2-01
Gravitational field strength·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Medium12 marks
Short answer & extended response12 steps to full marksDetermine

A rover on the surface of Mars carries a simple pendulum of length 0.800 m. A camera on the rover records that the pendulum completes 20 small oscillations in 58.4 s.

The radius of Mars is 3.39 × 106 m.

Diagram 1 shows the planet Mars as a circle. Diagram 2 shows a magnified small region of space just above the Martian surface, with a rover standing on the surface.MarsDiagram 1: MarsroversurfaceDiagram 2: region near the rover(magnified)
Diagram NOT to scale
(a)
(i)

State what is meant by the gravitational field strength at a point.

(1)
(ii)

Show that the gravitational field strength at the surface of Mars is about 3.7 N kg−1.

(2)
(b)

Calculate the mass of Mars.

(2)
(c)

Diagram 1 shows Mars. Diagram 2 shows a small region of space just above the surface near the rover, greatly magnified.

(i)

Draw, on Diagram 1, the gravitational field lines of Mars.

(2)
(ii)

Draw, on Diagram 2, the gravitational field lines in this region. Outline why they differ from the lines you drew on Diagram 1.

(2)
(d)

A pendulum clock keeps correct time on the Earth, where the gravitational field strength is 9.81 N kg−1. The clock is taken to Mars. Determine whether the clock runs fast or slow on Mars, and by how many minutes it is wrong after one hour of real time.

(3)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)(i)
«gravitational» force per unit mass acting on a small «point» mass placed at that point✓ 1Accept g = F/m with the symbols defined. Do not accept «acceleration due to gravity» alone.
Part (a)(ii)
T = 58.4/20 = 2.92 s✓ 1
g = 4π²l/T² = 4π² × 0.800/2.92² = 3.70 N kg−1✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to at least 3 s.f. Unrounded answer 3.704 N kg−1.
Part (b)
M = gR²/G = 3.70 × (3.39 × 106)²/6.67 × 10−11✓ 1Allow ECF from (a)(ii).
M = 6.38 × 1023 kg✓ 1Award [2] for CNA. Accept 6.3–6.4 × 1023 kg.
Part (c)(i)
straight radial lines, evenly spaced around the planet, meeting the surface at right angles✓ 1At least four lines. Lines end at the surface; they must not cross.
arrows on the lines pointing towards Mars «towards its centre»✓ 1Do not award if any arrow points away from the planet.
Part (c)(ii)
parallel, equally spaced, vertical lines with arrows pointing down towards the surface✓ 1
the region is very small compared with the radius of Mars, so the radial lines are almost parallel there and the field strength is almost the same everywhere in it «uniform field»✓ 1OWTTE
Part (d)
T ∝ 1/√g, so TMars/TEarth = √(9.81/3.70) = 1.63✓ 1Allow ECF from (a)(ii).
the period is longer on Mars, so the clock ticks less often and runs slow «loses time»✓ 1MP2 only scores if the period on Mars is stated or shown to be longer.
in one hour the clock records 3600/1.63 = 2210 s, so it is about 23 minutes slow✓ 1Accept 22–24 minutes.

Answers: (a)(ii) g = 3.70 N kg−1  ·  (b) M = 6.38 × 1023 kg  ·  (d) runs slow by about 23 min (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r²; gravitational field lines (linked to C.1 — T = 2π√(l/g)) Command term: Determine

13D-2-02
Variation of g with distance·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Medium11 marks
Short answer & extended response11 steps to full marksSketch

Mercury may be treated as a uniform sphere of radius R = 2.44 × 106 m. The graph shows how the gravitational field strength g due to Mercury varies with the distance r from the centre of Mercury, for r ≥ R.

G = 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2.

Graph of the gravitational field strength g due to Mercury against distance r from its centre, for r from 2.44 × 10^6 m to 14 × 10^6 m. g falls from 3.70 N/kg at the surface along an inverse-square curve.02468101214r / 10⁶ m01234g / N kg⁻¹
Graph drawn to scale
(a)

Determine, using the graph, the mass of Mercury.

(2)
(b)

Planet X, a uniform sphere, has the same mass as Mercury but twice its radius.

(i)

Sketch, on the graph, the variation of the gravitational field strength due to planet X with distance from its centre, from the surface of X outwards.

(2)
(ii)

Explain why the two graphs are the same at distances greater than 4.88 × 106 m.

(2)
(iii)

Deduce (mean density of planet X)/(mean density of Mercury).

(1)
(c)

A lander of mass 620 kg approaches Mercury.

(i)

Determine the magnitude of the gravitational force on the lander when it is at a height of 2R above the surface of Mercury.

(3)
(ii)

State the magnitude and direction of the gravitational force that the lander exerts on Mercury at this instant.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
a point read correctly from the curve, e.g. g = 1.38 N kg−1 at r = 4.0 × 106 m OR g = 3.70 N kg−1 at r = 2.44 × 106 m✓ 1Any correct reading; r must be in metres.
M = gr²/G = 1.38 × (4.0 × 106)²/6.67 × 10−11 = 3.3 × 1023 kg✓ 1Accept 3.2–3.4 × 1023 kg. Award [2] for CNA.
Part (b)(i)
line starts at r = 4.88 × 106 m «2R» with g ≈ 0.92 N kg−1 «one quarter of Mercury's surface value»✓ 1Accept a start between 0.85 and 1.0 N kg−1.
for r > 4.88 × 106 m the line lies on Mercury's curve; no line drawn for r < 4.88 × 106 m✓ 1Do not award MP2 for a separate curve that lies above or below Mercury's.
Part (b)(ii)
outside a uniform «spherically symmetric» body, the body acts as a point mass at its centre✓ 1OWTTE
g = GM/r² depends only on M and r, and the two masses are equal «so the radius of the body does not matter outside it»✓ 1
Part (b)(iii)
1/8 «the volume is 2³ = 8 times larger for the same mass»✓ 1Accept 0.125.
Part (c)(i)
distance from the centre r = 3R = 7.32 × 106 m✓ 1Do not accept 2R as the distance.
g = 3.70/3² = 0.411 N kg−1✓ 1Accept a value read from the graph, 0.40–0.42 N kg−1, or GM/r² with ECF from (a).
F = 620 × 0.411 = 255 N✓ 1Accept 248–260 N. Award [1 max] for 574 N «r = 2R used».
Part (c)(ii)
255 N directed towards the lander «away from the centre of Mercury»✓ 1Allow ECF from (c)(i). Both magnitude and direction needed. Newton's third law.

Answers: (a) 3.3 × 1023 kg  ·  (b)(iii) 1/8  ·  (c)(i) 255 N · (c)(ii) 255 N (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point, as given by g = F/m = GM/r²; conditions under which extended bodies can be treated as point masses; Newton's universal law of gravitation (linked to A.2 — Newton's third law) Command term: Sketch

14D-2-04
Combining two gravitational fields·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Hard12 marks
Short answer & extended response12 steps to full marksSketch

Pluto and its largest moon, Charon, may be treated as uniform spheres. In this question treat both bodies as stationary and ignore the gravitational fields of all other bodies.

The distance between the centres of Pluto and Charon is 1.96 × 107 m.

mass / kgradius / m
Pluto1.30 × 10221.19 × 106
Charon1.59 × 10216.06 × 105
Empty axes: resultant gravitational field strength, positive towards Charon, against distance from the centre of Pluto from 0 to 2.0 × 10^7 m. Dashed lines mark the surfaces of Pluto and of Charon.00.511.52distance from centre of Pluto / 10⁷ m-0.6-0.4-0.200.20.4resultant g / N kg⁻¹Pluto'ssurfaceCharon'ssurface
Axes drawn to scale
(a)

Outline why there is a point on the line between the centres of Pluto and Charon at which the resultant gravitational field strength is zero.

(2)
(b)
(i)

Show that this point is about 1.45 × 107 m from the centre of Pluto.

(2)
(ii)

A probe rests on the surface of Charon at the point nearest to Pluto. Determine the magnitude and direction of the resultant gravitational field strength at the probe.

(3)
(c)

On the axes, sketch a graph to show how the resultant gravitational field strength varies along the line joining the centres, from the surface of Pluto to the surface of Charon. Take field strength directed towards Charon as positive.

(3)
(d)

A small probe is placed at rest at the point in (b)(i) and is then displaced slightly towards Charon. Explain why the probe does not return to that point.

(2)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
between the bodies the two fields act in opposite directions «each towards its own body»✓ 1
each field decreases with distance from its own body «inverse square», so at some point the two magnitudes are equal✓ 1OWTTE
Part (b)(i)
GMP/x² = GMC/(d − x)² OR x/(d − x) = √(MP/MC) = 2.86✓ 1
x = 1.96 × 107 × 2.86/3.86 = 1.45 × 107 m✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to at least 3 s.f. Unrounded answer 1.452 × 107 m.
Part (b)(ii)
field of Charon at its surface = 6.67 × 10−11 × 1.59 × 1021/(6.06 × 105)² = 0.289 N kg−1✓ 1
field of Pluto at the probe = 6.67 × 10−11 × 1.30 × 1022/(1.90 × 107)² = 2.40 × 10−3 N kg−1✓ 1The distance from the centre of Pluto must be 1.96 × 107 − 6.06 × 105 m.
resultant = 0.286 N kg−1 towards the centre of Charon✓ 1Direction required. Award [2 max] if the fields are added (0.291 N kg−1).
Part (c)
negative near the surface of Pluto «about −0.6 N kg−1» and positive near the surface of Charon «about +0.3 N kg−1», with the magnitude at Pluto clearly the larger✓ 1Values need not be exact.
curve crosses zero once, at about 1.45 × 107 m «closer to Charon»✓ 1Allow ECF from (b)(i).
curve steepest close to each surface and flatter in between «1/r² shape»✓ 1Do not award for straight-line segments.
Part (d)
closer to Charon, Charon's field is larger and Pluto's is smaller, so the resultant field points towards Charon✓ 1
the resultant force accelerates the probe further away from the point «towards Charon»; the equilibrium is unstable✓ 1OWTTE

Answers: (b)(i) 1.45 × 107 m  ·  (b)(ii) 0.286 N kg−1 towards the centre of Charon (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r²; determination of the resultant gravitational field strength restricted to points along a line joining two bodies (guidance) Command term: Sketch

15D-2-15
Orbits and satellites·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Medium12 marks
Short answer & extended response12 steps to full marksExplain

A lunar orbiter moves in a circular orbit at a height of 100 km above the surface of the Moon.

Mass of the Moon = 7.35 × 1022 kg. Radius of the Moon = 1.74 × 106 m.

(a)
(i)

Explain why the speed of the orbiter is constant even though a resultant force acts on it.

(2)
(ii)

Show that the speed of the orbiter is about 1.6 km s−1.

(2)
(iii)

Calculate the time for one orbit, in minutes.

(1)
(b)

Tracking shows that orbits this low are disturbed above some regions of the Moon, where there are large masses of unusually dense rock below the surface.

(i)

State the condition under which the Moon can be treated as a point mass at its centre.

(1)
(ii)

Suggest why these dense regions disturb a low orbit much more than an orbit far from the Moon.

(3)
(c)

The orbiter must get rid of 350 W of waste thermal energy. It uses a flat radiator panel of area 0.80 m² and emissivity 0.90, which emits from one face only.

(i)

Determine the temperature of the panel when it emits 350 W. Ignore any radiation absorbed by the panel.

(2)
(ii)

Suggest why the panel must operate at a higher temperature when its emitting face points towards the sunlit surface of the Moon.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)(i)
the gravitational force is always perpendicular to the velocity «directed towards the centre of the Moon»✓ 1
so no work is done on the orbiter; its kinetic energy «speed» is unchanged and only the direction of its velocity changes✓ 1OWTTE
Part (a)(ii)
GMm/r² = mv²/r with r = 1.74 × 106 + 1.00 × 105 = 1.84 × 106 m✓ 1MP1 requires the orbit radius, not the height.
v = √(6.67 × 10−11 × 7.35 × 1022/1.84 × 106) = 1.63 × 103 m s−1✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to at least 3 s.f.
Part (a)(iii)
T = 2π × 1.84 × 106/1630 = 7.1 × 103 s = 118 min✓ 1Allow ECF from (a)(ii). Accept 117–119 min.
Part (b)(i)
its mass must be distributed with spherical symmetry «density depends only on the distance from the centre»✓ 1Accept «uniform sphere». Accept «the distance from the Moon is very large compared with its radius». OWTTE
Part (b)(ii)
a low orbit passes close to the dense regions✓ 1
the gravitational force decreases with the square of the distance, so at short range the extra pull of a dense region is relatively large «and is not directed towards the centre of the Moon»✓ 1
far from the Moon the distance is large compared with the size of the Moon, so it behaves as a point mass and local differences in density have little effect✓ 1OWTTE
Part (c)(i)
350 = 0.90 × 5.67 × 10−8 × 0.80 × T⁴✓ 1
T = 304 K✓ 1Award [2] for CNA. Accept 300–305 K.
Part (c)(ii)
the panel then absorbs infrared radiation emitted by the hot lunar surface «and reflected sunlight», so it must emit more power to remove the same 350 W✓ 1OWTTE

Answers: (a)(ii) v = 1.63 × 103 m s−1  ·  (a)(iii) 118 min  ·  (c)(i) 304 K (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = Gm1m2/r² for bodies treated as point masses; conditions under which extended bodies can be treated as point masses (linked to A.2 — centripetal force, and B.2 — emissivity) Command term: Explain

16D-1A-26
Density, mass and g·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AHard1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDetermine

Planet X has twice the radius of the Earth and the same mean density as the Earth.

What is the gravitational field strength at the surface of planet X, in terms of the Earth's surface value g?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1At the same density M = ρ × (4/3)πR³, so doubling R multiplies the mass by 2³ = 8.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2g = GM/R² → factor 8/2² = 2, so the field is 2g.✓ 1Answer B

Answer: B  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThis keeps the mass unchanged and allows only for the larger radius. A bigger planet of the same density is more massive.
  • BCorrect: M ∝ R³ at fixed density, so g ∝ R³/R² = R and the field doubles.
  • CThis divides the mass factor 8 by R (2) instead of by R² (4).
  • DThis is the mass factor alone, with no allowance for the greater distance from the centre.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Determine

17D-1A-27
Kepler's second law·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDeduce

The diagram shows the elliptical orbit of a comet around the Sun S. P and Q are the points of the orbit closest to and farthest from the Sun.

Which row identifies where the speed of the comet and the magnitude of its acceleration are greatest?

Elliptical orbit of a comet with the Sun at one focus; P is the closest point and Q the farthest pointSPQ
Diagram NOT accurately drawn
Greatest speedGreatest acceleration
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1Kepler's second law: the line from the Sun sweeps out equal areas in equal times, so the comet moves fastest where that line is shortest, at P.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2The acceleration is the field strength GM/r², which is also greatest where r is smallest, at P.✓ 1Answer A

Answer: A  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • ACorrect: both the speed (equal areas in equal times) and the acceleration (GM/r²) are greatest at the closest point.
  • BThe speed is right, but the acceleration is GM/r², largest where r is smallest, not where the comet is slowest.
  • CThis reverses the second law. To sweep equal areas the comet must move fastest where it is nearest the Sun.
  • DEqual areas in equal times does not mean equal speeds. On an ellipse the speed changes round the orbit.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion; Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = G m1m2/r² Command term: Deduce

18D-1A-28
Combining two gravitational fields·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AHard1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDetermine

Two spheres of mass M and 4M have their centres a distance d apart. Point P lies on the line through both centres, a distance d from the centre of the sphere of mass M, on the side away from the sphere of mass 4M.

What is the magnitude of the resultant gravitational field strength at P?

Sphere of mass M and sphere of mass 4M with centres a distance d apart; point P lies on the line a distance d beyond MPM4Mdd
Diagram NOT accurately drawn
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1Field of M at P: GM/d². Field of 4M at P (distance 2d): 4GM/(2d)² = GM/d².—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2P is outside the pair, so both fields point from P towards the spheres and add: 2GM/d².✓ 1Answer C

Answer: C  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThe two contributions are equal, but at P they point the same way; subtracting them to get zero treats them as opposite.
  • BThis subtracts the fields and uses GM/(2d)² for the larger sphere, leaving out its factor 4.
  • CCorrect: GM/d² + 4GM/(2d)² = 2GM/d², both directed from P towards the spheres.
  • DThis places the sphere of mass 4M a distance d from P instead of 2d.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is given by g = F/m = GM/r²; the resultant field is restricted to points along the line joining two bodies (guidance) Command term: Determine

19D-1A-29
Orbits and satellites·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AHard1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDetermine

A satellite moves in a circular orbit of radius r around a planet. The gravitational field strength of the planet at the orbit is g.

What is the orbital speed of the satellite?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1The gravitational force is the centripetal force: mg = mv²/r.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2v² = gr, so v = √(gr).✓ 1Answer A

Answer: A  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • ACorrect: mg = mv²/r gives v = √(gr).
  • BThis rearranges g = v²/r wrongly as v² = g/r.
  • CThis uses ½mv² = mgr, the speed after falling a height r in a uniform field, which is not an orbit.
  • DThis is v², not v: the square root has been left out.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Determine

20D-1A-30
Weightlessness & free fall·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksExplain

An astronaut in a space station 400 km above the Earth's surface floats freely inside the station.

Which statement is correct?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1At 400 km the field is still about 8.7 N kg−1, so the astronaut has weight.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2The astronaut and the station fall towards the Earth with the same acceleration, so no contact force acts between them: this is apparent weightlessness.✓ 1Answer C

Answer: C  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • AThe field there is about 8.7 N kg−1, only about 11 % less than at the surface.
  • BThere is no outward force on the astronaut; the unbalanced gravitational force provides the centripetal acceleration.
  • CCorrect: gravity gives the astronaut and the floor the same acceleration, so no contact force acts between them.
  • DWeight is the gravitational force, which does not depend on whether there is air.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Explain

21D-1A-31
Gravitational field strength·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AEasy1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark1 step to full marksCalculate

Planet Y has five times the mass of the Earth and twice the radius of the Earth.

What is (gravitational field strength at the surface of Y)/(gravitational field strength at the surface of the Earth)?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1g = GM/R², so g ∝ M/R²: ratio = 5/2² = 1.25.✓ 1Answer A

Answer: A  ·  1 stage of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • ACorrect: 5/2² = 1.25.
  • BThis divides by the radius ratio, 2, instead of its square.
  • CThis allows for the mass but not for the larger radius.
  • DThis multiplies by the square of the radius ratio instead of dividing by it.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Calculate

22D-1A-32
Gravitational field lines·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1AMedium1 mark
Multiple choice · 1 mark2 steps to full marksDescribe

Two identical spherical masses are held a fixed distance apart. A field-line diagram is drawn for the region around them.

Which statement about the diagram is correct?

Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Step 1At the midpoint the two equal masses produce fields that are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, so the resultant field is zero.—All 2 steps must be completed — there is no mark for a part-answer.
Step 2A zero field has no direction, so no field line passes through that point.✓ 1Answer A

Answer: A  ·  2 stages of work, one mark

Every option, and why

  • ACorrect: the resultant field at the midpoint is zero, so no line can be drawn through it.
  • BField lines never cross: the resultant field has only one direction at each point.
  • CGravity is only attractive, so every line points towards a mass.
  • DEqual spacing would mean a uniform field; here the field varies strongly with position.

Syllabus understandingD.1 — gravitational field lines Command term: Describe

23D-1B-11
Newton's law of gravitation·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1BHard11 marks
Data-based question11 steps to full marksDetermine

A student uses a school torsion balance to investigate the gravitational force between two spheres. A small lead sphere of mass 15.0 g is fixed to each end of a light beam hanging from a fine wire. A large lead sphere of mass 1.50 kg is placed near each small sphere, and the gravitational attraction twists the wire until the beam comes to rest. The balance has been calibrated so that the force F on each small sphere is found from the deflection of a laser spot.

The centre-to-centre separation r of each pair of spheres is varied. The uncertainty in r is ±0.5 mm and the uncertainty in F is ±0.20 × 10−10 N. The graph shows F against 1/r² with error bars.

r / m1/r² / m−2F / 10−10 N
0.0464736.93
0.0525.26
0.0602784.07
0.0702042.90
0.0851382.07
0.1001001.40
Gravitational force against the reciprocal of separation squared, with error bars01002003004005001/r² / m⁻²02468F / 10⁻¹⁰ N
Graph drawn to scale
(a)

Calculate 1/r² for r = 0.052 m and its absolute uncertainty.

(2)
(b)

Draw the line of best fit for the data.

(1)
(c)

Determine, using lines of maximum and minimum gradient, a value for the gravitational constant G and its absolute uncertainty.

(4)
(d)

The accepted value of G is 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2. Comment on the student's result.

(1)
(e)

Each small sphere is also attracted by the large sphere on the far side of the beam. Explain the effect of this on the value of G obtained.

(2)
(f)

Suggest one change to the apparatus that would reduce the percentage uncertainty in F.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
1/r² = 1/0.052² = 370 m−2✓ 1
fractional uncertainty = 2 × 0.5/52 = 1.9 %, so Δ(1/r²) = ±7 m−2 (1/r² = 370 ± 7 m−2)✓ 1Accept ±7 m−2 (±7.1). Award [0] for MP2 if the fractional uncertainty is not doubled.
Part (b)
Single straight line passing through all the error bars, close to the origin✓ 1
Part (c)
Best gradient ≈ 1.46 × 10−12 N m²✓ 1Accept 1.40–1.52 × 10−12 N m².
G = gradient/(Mm) = 1.46 × 10−12/(1.50 × 0.0150) = 6.5 × 10−11 N m² kg−2✓ 1Allow ECF from the candidate's gradient.
Max and min gradient lines drawn through all error bars, gradients ≈ 1.61 × 10−12 and 1.34 × 10−12 N m²✓ 1Accept any pair of lines that pass through all the error bars.
ΔG = ½(7.17 − 5.94) × 10−11 ≈ 0.6 × 10−11, so G = (6.5 ± 0.6) × 10−11 N m² kg−2✓ 1Accept ±0.4 to ±0.8 × 10−11. MP4 is for matching the precision of value and uncertainty.
Part (d)
The accepted value lies within the student's range of values, so the result is consistent with it (although the student's value is lower)✓ 1Allow ECF from (c).
Part (e)
The far large sphere pulls each small sphere in the opposite direction to the near sphere, so the net force measured is smaller than GMm/r²✓ 1OWTTE
The measured F values, the gradient and hence G are all too small / G is underestimated✓ 1Award MP2 only if the direction of the effect is correct.
Part (f)
Use large spheres of greater mass (or denser material) so the forces are larger while the absolute uncertainty in reading the deflection stays the same✓ 1OWTTE. Accept a longer light path to the scale so that the laser-spot deflection for a given force is larger.

Answers: (a) 1/r² = (370 ± 7) m−2  ·  (c) G = (6.5 ± 0.6) × 10−11 N m² kg−2 (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = Gm1m2/r² for bodies treated as point masses Command term: Determine

24D-1B-12
Kepler's third law·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1BMedium12 marks
Data-based question12 steps to full marksDetermine

A student uses a published exoplanet database to test Kepler's third law for the seven planets that orbit the star TRAPPIST-1. The table gives the orbital radius a of each planet in astronomical units (AU) and its orbital period T in days. The orbits may be treated as circular.

The student tests the relationship T = kan, where k and n are constants, by plotting lg (T / day) against lg (a / AU). Five of the points have been plotted.

Planeta / AUT / daylg (a / AU)lg (T / day)
b0.011541.511−1.9380.179
c0.015802.422
d0.022274.049−1.6520.607
e0.029256.101−1.5340.785
f0.038499.208−1.4150.964
g0.0468312.35
h0.0618918.77−1.2081.273
Log of orbital period against log of orbital radius for five planets−2−1.8−1.6−1.4−1.2lg (a / AU)00.20.40.60.811.21.4lg (T / day)
Graph drawn to scale
(a)

Complete the table for planets c and g.

(2)
(b)

Plot the points for planets c and g on the graph and draw the line of best fit for the data.

(2)
(c)

Determine the gradient of the line.

(2)
(d)

Kepler's third law predicts that T² is proportional to a³. Outline whether the data support this prediction.

(1)
(e)

The relationship T² = 4π²a³/(GM) applies, where M is the mass of the star. Determine, using the data for planet e, the mass of TRAPPIST-1 in kg. (1 AU = 1.50 × 1011 m)

(2)
(f)

The database gives a for planet e as (0.02925 ± 0.00025) AU; the uncertainty in T is negligible. Determine the absolute uncertainty in your answer to (e) and discuss whether your value agrees with the published mass of 0.0898 solar masses. (Mass of the Sun = 1.99 × 1030 kg)

(3)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
lg (a / AU): c = −1.801; g = −1.329✓ 1Accept 3 or 4 decimal places; do not accept 2 d.p.
lg (T / day): c = 0.384; g = 1.092✓ 1Accept 3 or 4 decimal places; do not accept 2 d.p.
Part (b)
Both points plotted correctly to within half a small square✓ 1Allow ECF from (a).
Single straight line of best fit through (or very close to) all seven points✓ 1
Part (c)
Gradient calculated from a large triangle (at least half the length of the line)✓ 1
gradient = 1.50✓ 1Accept 1.46 to 1.54. No unit.
Part (d)
Gradient ≈ 1.5 = 3/2, so T ∝ a3/2; squaring gives T² ∝ a³, which supports the prediction✓ 1Allow ECF from (c) if the candidate's gradient is within ±3 % of 1.5.
Part (e)
a = 0.02925 × 1.50 × 1011 = 4.388 × 109 m AND T = 6.101 × 86 400 = 5.271 × 105 s✓ 1Both conversions needed.
M = 4π²a³/(GT²) = 1.80 × 1029 kg✓ 1Accept 1.79–1.81 × 1029 kg.
Part (f)
percentage uncertainty in M = 3 × (0.00025/0.02925) × 100 = 2.6 %✓ 1
ΔM = 0.05 × 1029 kg, so M = (1.80 ± 0.05) × 1029 kg✓ 1MP2 is for matching precision of value and uncertainty. Allow ECF from (e).
Published mass = 0.0898 × 1.99 × 1030 = 1.79 × 1029 kg, which lies within the range 1.75–1.85 × 1029 kg, so the values agree✓ 1Accept comparison in solar masses: 0.0904 ± 0.0023 M☉.

Answers: (a) c: −1.801, 0.384; g: −1.329, 1.092  ·  (c) 1.50  ·  (e) M = 1.80 × 1029 kg  ·  (f) M = (1.80 ± 0.05) × 1029 kg (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion Command term: Determine

25D-1B-19
Kepler's second law·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 1BMedium9 marks
Data-based question9 steps to full marksExplain

A student tests Kepler's second law using a published ephemeris (a table of predicted planetary positions) for Mars. For five 10-day intervals, each starting a given number of days after Mars passes perihelion (its closest point to the Sun), the student records the angle Δθ through which Mars moves around the Sun during the interval and the distance r of Mars from the Sun at the middle of the interval. The ephemeris gives angles to the nearest 0.01°.

For a short interval, the area swept out by the line joining Mars to the Sun is approximately ½r²Δθ, with Δθ in radians.

Start of interval / days after perihelionr / AUΔθ / °1/r² / AU−2
01.38156.350.524
951.44595.79
1811.55495.010.414
2671.64114.50
3431.66594.360.360
Angle moved in ten days against the reciprocal of distance squared for Mars00.10.20.30.40.50.61/r² / AU⁻²01234567Δθ / °
Graph drawn to scale
(a)

Complete the table.

(1)
(b)

Draw the line of best fit for the data.

(1)
(c)

Explain how the graph supports Kepler's second law.

(2)
(d)

Calculate, in m², the area swept out in 10 days starting at perihelion. (1 AU = 1.50 × 1011 m)

(2)
(e)

Explain why the student used the angle moved in 10 days rather than the angle moved in 1 day or in 100 days.

(2)
(f)

Determine the percentage difference between the values of r²Δθ at perihelion (0 days) and at 343 days, and comment on your answer.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
0.478 AND 0.371 AU−2✓ 1Both needed, to 3 s.f. (3 d.p.).
Part (b)
Single straight line through (or very close to) all the points, passing through (or very close to) the origin✓ 1
Part (c)
The graph is a straight line through the origin, so Δθ ∝ 1/r² / r²Δθ is constant✓ 1
The area swept out in each 10-day interval, ½r²Δθ, is therefore the same: equal areas are swept out in equal times✓ 1OWTTE
Part (d)
r = 1.3815 × 1.50 × 1011 = 2.072 × 1011 m AND Δθ = 6.35 × π/180 = 0.1108 rad✓ 1
area = ½ × (2.072 × 1011)² × 0.1108 = 2.38 × 1021 m²✓ 1Accept 2.37–2.39 × 1021 m².
Part (e)
In 1 day Δθ is only about 0.4–0.6°, so the ±0.005° rounding gives a percentage uncertainty about ten times larger✓ 1OWTTE
In 100 days r changes considerably, so ½r²Δθ with a single value of r is no longer a good approximation to the area✓ 1OWTTE
Part (f)
r²Δθ = 12.12 and 12.10 AU² degrees, a difference of about 0.16 %, which is within the rounding uncertainty of the angles (0.005/6.35 + 0.005/4.36 ≈ 0.19 %), so r²Δθ is constant: consistent with Kepler's second law✓ 1Accept any comparison showing the difference is very small / within uncertainty.

Answers: (a) 0.478, 0.371 AU−2  ·  (d) 2.38 × 1021 m²  ·  (f) about 0.16 % (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion Command term: Explain

26D-2-16
Density, mass and g·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Hard13 marks
Short answer & extended response13 steps to full marksShow that

Many small asteroids are "rubble piles": collections of loose rocks held together only by their own gravity.

Asteroid R is modelled as a uniform sphere of radius 250 m and mean density 2.0 × 103 kg m−3. It rotates about its axis once every 3.6 hours.

Part of the surface of asteroid R at its equator, with a loose rock resting on the top of the surface; a dashed line points from the rock towards the centre of R.rocktowards the centre of Rasteroid R
Diagram NOT to scale
(a)
(i)

Show that the mass of R is about 1.3 × 1011 kg.

(1)
(ii)

Calculate the gravitational field strength at the surface of R.

(2)
(b)

A loose rock of mass 5.0 kg rests on the surface of R at its equator, as shown in the diagram.

(i)

Draw and label, on the diagram, the forces acting on the rock. The lengths of your arrows should show the relative sizes of the forces.

(2)
(ii)

Determine the normal force exerted on the rock by the surface.

(4)
(c)
(i)

Show that the shortest period of rotation that a rubble pile of mean density ρ can have without losing rocks from its equator is √(3π/(Gρ)).

(2)
(ii)

Calculate this shortest period for R, in hours.

(1)
(iii)

Surveys show that almost no asteroids wider than a few hundred metres rotate faster than once every 2.2 hours, but many smaller asteroids rotate once every few minutes. Suggest what this shows about these small, fast-rotating asteroids.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)(i)
M = ρ × (4/3)πR³ = 2.0 × 103 × (4/3)π × 250³ = 1.31 × 1011 kg✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to at least 3 s.f.
Part (a)(ii)
g = GM/R² = 6.67 × 10−11 × 1.31 × 1011/250²✓ 1
g = 1.40 × 10−4 N kg−1✓ 1Award [2] for CNA.
Part (b)(i)
weight «gravitational force» towards the centre of R AND normal «reaction» force away from the centre, both labelled✓ 1Do not award if a «centripetal force» is added as a third force.
weight arrow longer than the normal force arrow, both starting on the rock✓ 1
Part (b)(ii)
ω = 2π/(3.6 × 3600) = 4.85 × 10−4 rad s−1✓ 1ALTERNATIVE: v = 2πR/T = 0.121 m s−1, then a = v²/R.
centripetal acceleration a = ω²R = 5.88 × 10−5 m s−2✓ 1
the resultant force is towards the centre: mg − N = ma, so N = m(g − a)✓ 1Allow ECF from (a)(ii).
N = 5.0 × (1.40 × 10−4 − 5.88 × 10−5) = 4.1 × 10−4 N «4.0 × 10−4 N with unrounded values»✓ 1Accept 4.0–4.1 × 10−4 N. Award [1 max] for N = mg = 7.0 × 10−4 N.
Part (c)(i)
at the shortest period N = 0, so gravity alone provides the centripetal force: GM/R² = ω²R✓ 1
with M = (4/3)πρR³: ω² = 4πGρ/3, so T = 2π/ω = √(3π/(Gρ))✓ 1R must be seen to cancel.
Part (c)(ii)
T = √(3π/(6.67 × 10−11 × 2.0 × 103)) = 8.4 × 103 s = 2.3 h✓ 1Accept 2.3–2.4 h.
Part (c)(iii)
they cannot be held together by gravity alone, so they must be single solid bodies «held together by the strength of the rock»✓ 1OWTTE

Answers: (a)(ii) g = 1.40 × 10−4 N kg−1  ·  (b)(ii) N = 4.0–4.1 × 10−4 N  ·  (c)(ii) 2.3 h (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² (linked to A.2 — free-body diagrams and centripetal acceleration a = ω²r) Command term: Show that

27D-2-17
Kepler's laws·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Medium14 marks
Short answer & extended response14 steps to full marksState

A spacecraft travels from the Earth to Mars on a transfer orbit around the Sun. The transfer orbit is half of an ellipse. Its closest point to the Sun, P, lies on the orbit of the Earth, 1.00 AU from the Sun. Its farthest point from the Sun, A, lies on the orbit of Mars, 1.52 AU from the Sun. The engines are switched off between P and A.

Treat the orbits of the Earth and Mars as circles. The period of the Earth's orbit is 1.00 year.

The Sun with the circular orbits of the Earth (radius 1.00 AU) and Mars (radius 1.52 AU), dashed. The transfer orbit is half an ellipse from P on the Earth's orbit to A on the orbit of Mars, travelled anticlockwise; X is a point on it between P and A.SunPAXEarth's orbitorbit of Mars
Diagram NOT to scale
(a)
(i)

State Kepler's first law as it applies to the transfer orbit.

(1)
(ii)

Draw and label arrows on the diagram to show the direction of the gravitational force on the spacecraft and the direction of its velocity when it is at X.

(2)
(iii)

Explain, with reference to your answer to (a)(ii), why the spacecraft slows down as it moves from P to A.

(2)
(b)
(i)

Calculate (gravitational field strength of the Sun at P)/(gravitational field strength of the Sun at A).

(1)
(ii)

State Kepler's second law.

(1)
(iii)

At P and at A the velocity of the spacecraft is perpendicular to the line joining it to the Sun. The speed of the spacecraft at P is 32.7 km s−1. Using Kepler's second law, determine its speed at A.

(3)
(c)

Kepler's third law also applies to an elliptical orbit if the orbital radius is replaced by half of the sum of the greatest and the smallest distances from the Sun.

(i)

Determine the time taken by the spacecraft to travel from P to A, in days.

(3)
(ii)

Suggest why the spacecraft must be launched from the Earth at a particular time.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)(i)
the transfer orbit is an ellipse with the Sun at one focus✓ 1Do not accept «the Sun at the centre».
Part (a)(ii)
force arrow from X pointing towards the Sun, labelled✓ 1
velocity arrow from X along the tangent to the path, in the direction of motion «towards A», labelled✓ 1The velocity arrow must not be drawn perpendicular to the force arrow.
Part (a)(iii)
the angle between the force and the velocity is greater than 90°, so the force has a component opposite to the velocity✓ 1Allow ECF from (a)(ii).
so the gravitational force does negative work on the spacecraft and its kinetic energy decreases✓ 1Accept «the component of the force along the path decelerates it». OWTTE
Part (b)(i)
g ∝ 1/r², so the ratio is (1.52/1.00)² = 2.31✓ 1
Part (b)(ii)
the line joining the Sun and an orbiting body sweeps out equal areas in equal times✓ 1
Part (b)(iii)
in a short time Δt the area swept out is ½rvΔt, at P and at A✓ 1
equal areas in equal times, so rPvP = rAvA✓ 1
vA = 32.7 × 1.00/1.52 = 21.5 km s−1✓ 1Award [1 max] for a bare answer with no use of Kepler's second law. Do not accept 49.7 km s−1.
Part (c)(i)
half of the sum of the distances = (1.00 + 1.52)/2 = 1.26 AU✓ 1
T² ∝ r³ compared with the Earth: T = 1.00 × 1.263/2 = 1.41 years✓ 1
P to A is half an orbit: ½ × 1.414 × 365 = 258 days✓ 1Award [2 max] for a whole orbit «516 days». Accept 257–259 days.
Part (c)(ii)
Mars must reach A at the same time as the spacecraft, so the Earth and Mars must be in a particular relative position at launch✓ 1OWTTE

Answers: (b)(i) 2.31  ·  (b)(iii) 21.5 km s−1  ·  (c)(i) 258 days (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion; that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² (linked to A.3 — work done by a force) Command term: State

28D-2-18
Geostationary orbits·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Medium13 marks
Short answer & extended response13 steps to full marksEstimate

A communications satellite S is in a geostationary orbit around the Earth. The period of the orbit is 8.62 × 104 s.

Mass of the Earth = 5.97 × 1024 kg. Radius of the Earth = 6.37 × 106 m.

The equipment on S needs 4.0 kW of electrical power. In sunlight the power comes from solar panels; in the Earth's shadow it comes from batteries.

The Earth seen from above the North Pole N, rotating anticlockwise, with the circular geostationary orbit (dashed) and the satellite S on it. Sunlight arrives from the left and the Earth's shadow is a band extending to the right.shadowNEarth's rotationSsunlight
Diagram NOT to scale
(a)
(i)

Draw an arrow on the diagram to show the direction of the velocity of S.

(1)
(ii)

Outline why a geostationary orbit must lie in the plane of the equator.

(2)
(iii)

Show that the radius of the orbit is about 4.2 × 107 m.

(2)
(b)
(i)

Calculate the speed of S.

(1)
(ii)

For a few weeks each year S passes through the Earth's shadow once a day. Treat the shadow as a band whose width is equal to the diameter of the Earth. Estimate the longest time that S spends in the shadow.

(2)
(iii)

The fully charged batteries can deliver 1.8 × 107 J. Determine whether they can keep the equipment working for the whole of the time in (b)(ii).

(2)
(c)
(i)

Calculate the shortest time for a radio signal to travel from a ground station directly below S up to S and back to the ground.

(2)
(ii)

Suggest one reason why some internet services use satellites in low orbits rather than geostationary satellites.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)(i)
arrow at S along the tangent to the orbit, pointing anticlockwise «the same sense as the Earth's rotation»✓ 1
Part (a)(ii)
the gravitational force on S is directed towards the centre of the Earth, so the centre of the orbit must be the centre of the Earth✓ 1
S must stay above one point on the rotating Earth, which moves in a circle about the axis; only the equator's circle has the centre of the Earth as its centre✓ 1OWTTE
Part (a)(iii)
GMm/r² = 4π²mr/T², so r³ = GMT²/4π²✓ 1
r = (6.67 × 10−11 × 5.97 × 1024 × (8.62 × 104)²/4π²)1/3 = 4.22 × 107 m✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to at least 3 s.f.
Part (b)(i)
v = 2πr/T = 2π × 4.22 × 107/8.62 × 104 = 3.07 × 103 m s−1✓ 1Allow ECF from (a)(iii).
Part (b)(ii)
distance travelled in the shadow ≈ 2 × 6.37 × 106 = 1.27 × 107 m✓ 1
t = 1.27 × 107/3.07 × 103 = 4.1 × 103 s «≈ 69 min»✓ 1Allow ECF from (b)(i). Accept 4.0–4.2 × 103 s.
Part (b)(iii)
energy needed = 4.0 × 103 × 4.1 × 103 = 1.6 × 107 J «1.7 × 107 J with the unrounded time»✓ 1Allow ECF from (b)(ii).
this is less than 1.8 × 107 J, so the batteries are «just» sufficient✓ 1The conclusion must be consistent with the candidate's energy.
Part (c)(i)
height = 4.22 × 107 − 6.37 × 106 = 3.58 × 107 m✓ 1
t = 2 × 3.58 × 107/3.00 × 108 = 0.24 s✓ 1Award [1 max] for 0.28 s «orbit radius used instead of height».
Part (c)(ii)
the signal travels a much shorter distance, so the delay is much smaller✓ 1Accept another valid reason, e.g. less powerful transmitters are needed. OWTTE

Answers: (a)(iii) r = 4.22 × 107 m  ·  (b)(i) v = 3.07 × 103 m s−1  ·  (b)(ii) 4.1 × 103 s  ·  (b)(iii) 1.6–1.7 × 107 J «sufficient»  ·  (c)(i) 0.24 s (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion; Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = Gm1m2/r² for bodies treated as point masses (linked to A.3 — power, and C.2 — the speed of electromagnetic waves) Command term: Estimate

29D-2-19
Gravitational field strength·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Easy10 marks
Short answer & extended response10 steps to full marksCalculate

Rhea is one of the moons of Saturn. It may be treated as a uniform sphere of mass 2.31 × 1021 kg and radius 7.64 × 105 m, and it has no atmosphere. A robotic lander of mass 450 kg is designed to explore its surface.

G = 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2; gravitational field strength at the surface of the Earth = 9.81 N kg−1.

(a)

Show that the gravitational field strength at the surface of Rhea is about 0.26 N kg−1.

(1)
(b)

The engine of the lander can provide a maximum upward thrust of 300 N.

(i)

Determine whether this engine could hold the lander at rest just above the surface of Rhea, and whether it could do so just above the surface of the Earth.

(2)
(ii)

Calculate the initial acceleration of the lander when it lifts off from Rhea with the engine at maximum thrust.

(2)
(c)

The lander releases a small sensor from rest at a height of 12.0 m above the surface.

(i)

Calculate the time taken for the sensor to reach the surface.

(2)
(ii)

Outline why the gravitational field strength may be treated as constant during this fall.

(1)
(d)

A rock sample collected by the lander has a weight of 0.50 N on Rhea.

Calculate the weight of the sample on the Earth.

(2)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
g = 6.67 × 10−11 × 2.31 × 1021 / (7.64 × 105)² = 0.264 «N kg−1»✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to 3 s.f.
Part (b)(i)
weight on Rhea = 450 × 0.264 = 119 N, which is less than 300 N, so the lander can hover above Rhea✓ 1Allow ECF from (a).
weight on the Earth = 450 × 9.81 = 4.41 × 103 N, which is greater than 300 N, so it cannot hover above the Earth✓ 1A conclusion without a calculated weight scores [0] for that mark.
Part (b)(ii)
resultant «upward» force = 300 − 119 = 181 N✓ 1Allow ECF from (b)(i).
a = 181 / 450 = 0.40 m s−2✓ 1Accept 0.40–0.41 m s−2. Award [2] for CNA.
Part (c)(i)
s = ½gt², so t = √(2 × 12.0 / 0.264)✓ 1Allow ECF from (a).
t = 9.5 s✓ 1Accept 9.5–9.6 s. Award [2] for CNA. An answer of 1.6 s «uses g = 9.81 N kg−1» scores [0].
Part (c)(ii)
12.0 m is negligible compared with the radius «7.64 × 105 m», so the distance from the centre and hence g change by a negligible fraction «≈ 0.003 %»✓ 1OWTTE. Accept “the field near the surface is «approximately» uniform over such a small height”.
Part (d)
mass of sample = 0.50 / 0.264 = 1.89 kg «the mass is the same on both bodies»✓ 1Allow ECF from (a).
weight on the Earth = 1.89 × 9.81 = 18.6 N✓ 1Accept 18.6–18.9 N. Award [2] for CNA.

Answers: (a) 0.264 N kg−1  ·  (b)(i) 119 N on Rhea (yes); 4.41 × 103 N on the Earth (no)  ·  (b)(ii) 0.40 m s−2  ·  (c)(i) 9.5 s  ·  (d) 18.6 N (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r². Links: A.1 — equations of motion for uniform acceleration; A.2 — Newton's second law of motion Command term: Calculate

30D-2-20
Kepler's third law·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Hard11 marks
Short answer & extended response11 steps to full marksDetermine

A star has a mass M = 0.80 M☉ and a luminosity of 0.35 L☉. A planet moves around the star in a circular orbit of radius r with a period T of 150 days. For a circular orbit, T² = (4π²/GM) r³.

M☉ = 1.99 × 1030 kg; L☉ = 3.83 × 1026 W; G = 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2; σ = 5.67 × 10−8 W m−2 K−4.

(a)

State Kepler's third law.

(1)
(b)

Calculate r.

(2)
(c)

Show that the intensity of the star's radiation at the distance of the planet is about 1.8 × 103 W m−2.

(1)
(d)

The planet has an albedo of 0.30 and its surface emits as a black body.

(i)

Determine the equilibrium temperature of the planet's surface, ignoring any effect of an atmosphere.

(3)
(ii)

Suggest why the actual mean surface temperature of the planet could be higher than your answer to (d)(i).

(2)
(e)

The luminosity of the star is known only to within ±10 %.

Estimate the resulting absolute uncertainty in your answer to (d)(i).

(2)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
the square of the orbital period is proportional to the cube of the «mean» orbital radius «for bodies orbiting the same central body»✓ 1Accept T² ∝ r³ with the symbols identified. Accept “semi-major axis” for radius.
Part (b)
T = 150 × 86 400 = 1.30 × 107 s AND M = 0.80 × 1.99 × 1030 = 1.59 × 1030 kg substituted into r³ = GMT²/4π²✓ 1
r = 7.67 × 1010 m✓ 1Accept 7.6–7.7 × 1010 m «≈ 0.51 AU». Award [2] for CNA. Do not award MP2 if T is left in days.
Part (c)
I = 0.35 × 3.83 × 1026 / (4π × (7.67 × 1010)²) = 1.81 × 103 «W m−2»✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to 3 s.f.
Part (d)(i)
mean intensity over the whole surface = I/4 «= 453 W m−2»✓ 1Allow ECF from (c). Use of 1.8 × 103 W m−2 is acceptable.
σT⁴ = (1 − 0.30) × I/4 «= 317 W m−2»✓ 1
T = 273 K✓ 1Accept 270–276 K. Award [3] for CNA. Omitting the factor ¼ gives 387 K: award [2].
Part (d)(ii)
an atmosphere containing greenhouse gases «such as CO₂, H₂O, CH₄» absorbs infrared radiation emitted by the surface✓ 1OWTTE
the gases re-emit infrared in all directions, so some returns to the surface «and the surface must be hotter to lose energy at the rate it gains it»✓ 1Do not accept “traps heat” alone.
Part (e)
T ∝ L1/4, so the fractional uncertainty in T is ¼ × 10 % = 2.5 %✓ 1
absolute uncertainty ≈ ±7 K✓ 1Accept ±6 K to ±7 K. Allow ECF from (d)(i).

Answers: (b) 7.67 × 1010 m  ·  (c) 1.81 × 103 W m−2  ·  (d)(i) 273 K  ·  (e) ±7 K (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Kepler's three laws of orbital motion; Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = Gm1m2/r² for bodies treated as point masses. Links: B.1 — apparent brightness b = L/4πd²; B.2 — albedo, mean incoming intensity and the greenhouse effect; Tools — propagation of uncertainties Command term: Determine

31D-2-21
Newton's law of gravitation·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Hard11 marks
Short answer & extended response11 steps to full marksExplain

At new moon the Moon M lies on the straight line between the Sun S and the Earth E, as shown in the diagram.

Mass of the Sun = 1.99 × 1030 kg; mass of the Earth = 5.97 × 1024 kg; mass of the Moon = 7.35 × 1022 kg; distance between the centres of the Earth and the Moon = 3.84 × 108 m; distance between the centres of the Sun and the Moon = 1.50 × 1011 m; G = 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2.

The Sun, the Moon and the Earth on one straight line at new moon (not to scale)Sun SMoon MEarth E
Diagram NOT to scale
(a)
(i)

Show that the gravitational force exerted by the Earth on the Moon is about 2.0 × 1020 N.

(1)
(ii)

Calculate the gravitational force exerted by the Sun on the Moon.

(1)
(b)

Draw and label, on the diagram, arrows to represent the two gravitational forces acting on the Moon. The lengths of your arrows should show the relative sizes of the forces.

(2)
(c)

Determine the magnitude and direction of the resultant gravitational field strength at the centre of the Moon.

(3)
(d)

Part (a) shows that the Sun pulls on the Moon more strongly than the Earth does.

(i)

Calculate the gravitational field strength due to the Sun at the centre of the Earth at the same instant.

(1)
(ii)

Explain, using your answers to (c) and (d)(i), why the Moon nevertheless continues to orbit the Earth.

(3)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)(i)
F = 6.67 × 10−11 × 5.97 × 1024 × 7.35 × 1022 / (3.84 × 108)² = 1.98 × 1020 «N»✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to 3 s.f.
Part (a)(ii)
F = 6.67 × 10−11 × 1.99 × 1030 × 7.35 × 1022 / (1.50 × 1011)² = 4.34 × 1020 N✓ 1
Part (b)
one arrow from M towards S and one from M towards E, each labelled «e.g. force of Sun, force of Earth»✓ 1Arrows should start at, or touch, M.
arrow towards S about twice as long as arrow towards E «ratio 2.2»✓ 1Accept a length ratio between 1.8 and 2.6. Allow ECF from (a).
Part (c)
field of the Sun = 5.90 × 10−3 N kg−1 towards S✓ 1ALTERNATIVE: resultant force from (a) divided by the mass of the Moon, for MP1 and MP2.
field of the Earth = 2.70 × 10−3 N kg−1 towards E✓ 1
resultant = 3.20 × 10−3 N kg−1 towards the Sun✓ 1Accept 3.1–3.3 × 10−3 N kg−1. Direction needed for MP3. Allow ECF from (a).
Part (d)(i)
g = 6.67 × 10−11 × 1.99 × 1030 / (1.504 × 1011)² = 5.87 × 10−3 N kg−1✓ 1Must see the distance 1.50 × 1011 + 3.84 × 108 = 1.504 × 1011 m used. Accept 5.86–5.88 × 10−3 N kg−1.
Part (d)(ii)
the Sun gives the Earth and the Moon almost the same acceleration «≈ 5.9 × 10−3 m s−2», so the Earth and the Moon move around the Sun together✓ 1OWTTE
the difference between the Sun's field at the Moon and at the Earth is only about 3 × 10−5 N kg−1✓ 1Allow ECF from (c) and (d)(i).
this is about 1 % of the Earth's field at the Moon «2.70 × 10−3 N kg−1», so relative to the Earth the Moon's motion is controlled by the Earth's pull✓ 1Award MP3 only if a comparison with the Earth's field at the Moon is made.

Answers: (a)(i) 1.98 × 1020 N  ·  (a)(ii) 4.34 × 1020 N  ·  (c) 3.20 × 10−3 N kg−1 towards the Sun  ·  (d)(i) 5.87 × 10−3 N kg−1 (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — Newton's universal law of gravitation as given by F = Gm1m2/r² for bodies treated as point masses; that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r² Command term: Explain

32D-2-22
Variation of g with distance·D.1 Gravitational fields
Paper 2Medium9 marks
Short answer & extended response9 steps to full marksDetermine

A geophysicist searches for buried ore with a gravimeter, an instrument that can detect a change in the gravitational field strength of 5.0 × 10−8 N kg−1. An ore body may be modelled as a uniform sphere of radius 40 m whose centre is 150 m below the surface. Its density is 2500 kg m−3 greater than that of the surrounding rock.

G = 6.67 × 10−11 N m² kg−2; g at the surface = 9.81 N kg−1; radius of the Earth R = 6.37 × 106 m.

(a)

Show that the extra mass of the ore body, compared with the same volume of surrounding rock, is about 6.7 × 108 kg.

(1)
(b)

Calculate the increase in the gravitational field strength at the surface directly above the centre of the ore body.

(2)
(c)

Determine whether the gravimeter could detect the same ore body if its centre were 1.2 km below the surface.

(2)
(d)

The gravimeter contains a mass hanging from a spring, which is extended by 0.040 m.

Calculate the change in the extension of the spring caused by the ore body in (b).

(2)
(e)

For a small height h above the surface, the gravitational field strength of the Earth decreases by approximately 2gh/R.

(i)

Determine the change in height of the gravimeter that would produce the same change in gravitational field strength as the ore body in (b).

(1)
(ii)

Suggest, using your answer to (e)(i), one precaution the geophysicist must take during the survey.

(1)
Show mark scheme
Marking pointMarkNotes
Part (a)
Δm = 4/3 × π × 40³ × 2500 = 6.70 × 108 «kg»✓ 1Must see full substitution OR answer to 3 s.f.
Part (b)
Δg = GΔm/d² = 6.67 × 10−11 × 6.7 × 108 / 150² «the sphere acts as a point mass at its centre»✓ 1Allow ECF from (a).
Δg = 2.0 × 10−6 N kg−1✓ 1Award [2] for CNA.
Part (c)
Δg = 6.67 × 10−11 × 6.7 × 108 / 1200² = 3.1 × 10−8 N kg−1✓ 1ALTERNATIVE: Δg falls by a factor (1200/150)² = 64, giving 3.1 × 10−8 N kg−1.
this is less than 5.0 × 10−8 N kg−1, so it could not be detected✓ 1Conclusion must follow from a calculation. Allow ECF from (b).
Part (d)
kx = mg, so x ∝ g and Δx = x Δg/g✓ 1
Δx = 0.040 × 1.99 × 10−6 / 9.81 = 8.1 × 10−9 m✓ 1Accept 8.1–8.2 × 10−9 m. Allow ECF from (b). Award [2] for CNA.
Part (e)(i)
h = Δg R / 2g = 2.0 × 10−6 × 6.37 × 106 / (2 × 9.81) = 0.65 m✓ 1Accept 0.63–0.66 m. Allow ECF from (b).
Part (e)(ii)
measure the height of the gravimeter at every station to within a few centimetres and correct the readings for it✓ 1OWTTE. Accept any precaution clearly linked to height errors.

Answers: (a) 6.70 × 108 kg  ·  (b) 2.0 × 10−6 N kg−1  ·  (c) 3.1 × 10−8 N kg−1; no  ·  (d) 8.1 × 10−9 m  ·  (e)(i) 0.65 m (the remaining parts are explanations — see the table above)

Syllabus understandingD.1 — that gravitational field strength g at a point is the force per unit mass experienced by a small point mass at that point as given by g = F/m = GM/r²; conditions under which extended bodies can be treated as point masses. Links: B.1 — density ρ = m/V; A.2 — Hooke's law Command term: Determine

Marks are lost on method, not on knowledge

One-to-one tuition with a teacher who knows how IB physics marks are awarded, where they are withheld, and why.

Book a free consultation
ExaminerPrep ACHIEVE EXCELLENCE
This website uses cookies